top of page

European Restriction Proposal for Octocrylene (CAS 6197-30-4)

5 days ago
8 min read

Convergences and Divergences in Environmental Risk Assessment Between the French Restriction Dossier and the ECHA Risk Assessment Committee (RAC) Opinion


1. Octocrylene Restriction: Regulatory Background and French Proposal


Octocrylene (EC No. 228-250-8, CAS No. 6197-30-4) is a liquid, lipophilic, broad-spectrum chemical UV filter authorised for use in sunscreen products at concentrations of up to 9–10% [1, 2, 3]. In response to growing concerns about widespread contamination of aquatic and terrestrial environments, the French Agency for Food, Environmental and Occupational Health & Safety (ANSES), acting on behalf of France, prepared a restriction dossier under Annex XV of the REACH Regulation, which was formally submitted to the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) on 18 July 2025 [1].


The French dossier demonstrates that the widespread dispersive use of finished cosmetic products is the main driver of environmental emissions of Octocrylene, with an estimated annual volume of 1,752 tonnes on the European market [1, 2].

To address the unacceptable risks identified in freshwater, marine waters, sediments and agricultural soils, France proposed a restriction (Restriction Option 1, or RO1) prohibiting the placing on the market of finished cosmetic products containing Octocrylene at concentrations equal to or greater than 0.001% w/w (10 ppm), with a two-year transition period following its entry into force [1, 2].


2. Areas of Convergence in Environmental Risk Assessment


Following a comprehensive assessment completed on 4 June 2026, ECHA's Committee for Risk Assessment (RAC) confirmed most of the risk findings presented in the French restriction dossier, supporting the need for a harmonised restriction across the European Union [2].


2.1. Predominant Contribution of Emissions from Cosmetic Products

The RAC agrees with the French assessment that sunscreen products represent the main and almost exclusive source of Octocrylene releases into the environment [1, 2]. The RAC confirms an annual European tonnage of 1,752 tonnes of Octocrylene used in cosmetic products, of which approximately 1,473–1,665 tonnes per year enter wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) directly through washing and showering activities [1, 2]. Furthermore, the RAC supports the French assumption that 100% of the Octocrylene contained in applied sunscreen products is eventually released into the environment, either through direct wash-off during swimming (20% released directly into water) or through domestic wastewater (80% entering WWTPs) [1, 2].


 2.2. Toxicity to Aquatic Organisms

Regarding aquatic hazard assessment, the RAC fully supports France's identification of the freshwater invertebrate Daphnia magna as the most sensitive species and the primary basis for hazard characterisation [1, 2]. The RAC confirms the reliability of the 21-day chronic reproduction study (OECD TG 211), which establishes a No Observed Effect Concentration (NOEC) of 2.66 µg/L [1, 2]. However, the RAC supports the use of an EC10 (10% Effect Concentration) of 4.58 µg/L, considering this endpoint to be the most relevant and reliable parameter within the available aquatic toxicity dataset [2]..


2.3. Risk Characterisation for Sediments and Agricultural Soils

For sediment-dwelling and terrestrial organisms, the RAC fully endorses the threshold values selected by ANSES [1, 2]:

  • Sediments: The RAC validates the NOEC of 46.3 mg/kg dry weight (dw), based on a 28-day study with the oligochaete Lumbriculus variegatus (OECD TG 225). This results in Predicted No Effect Concentrations (PNECs) for sediments of 0.926 mg/kg dw in freshwater environments and 0.0926 mg/kg dw in marine environments [1, 2].

  • Soils: The RAC validates the NOEC of 19.5 mg/kg dw derived from a mung bean (Vigna radiata) seedling emergence test, resulting in a soil PNEC of 1.95 mg/kg dw after normalisation to 2% organic carbon content [1, 2].


2.4. Assessment of Bioaccumulation Criteria

The RAC agrees with the formal conclusion of the French dossier that Octocrylene does not strictly meet the numerical criteria for classification as Bioaccumulative (B) or very Bioaccumulative (vB) under Annex XIII of REACH. The bioconcentration factor (BCF), normalised to wet weight, remains below the regulatory threshold of 2,000 L/kg in standard fish bioaccumulation studies conducted according to OECD TG 305 [1, 2]. Nevertheless, the RAC shares France's concerns regarding in situ biomonitoring data demonstrating significant potential for biological accumulation in molluscs (mussels), corals and higher-level predators such as dolphins and tuna [1, 2].

 

2.5. Need for an EU-Wide Restriction Under REACH

The RAC and the Committee for Socio-economic Analysis (SEAC) confirm the French assessment that no existing regulatory measures, including the Water Framework Directive, the Marine Strategy Framework Directive, or regional marine conventions such as OSPAR and the Barcelona Convention, adequately control the direct and widespread emissions associated with recreational swimming activities [1, 2]. A harmonised EU-wide restriction under REACH is therefore considered the only appropriate and effective regulatory measure [1, 2].


2.6. Concentration Limit of 0.001% and Two-Year Transition Period (RO1)

The RAC supports the concentration limit of 0.001% w/w (10 ppm) proposed by France, which is too low for Octocrylene to perform its intended function as a UV filter.

In practice, this restriction would effectively prohibit the intentional incorporation of Octocrylene into cosmetic formulations while allowing unavoidable trace impurities. It would therefore amount to an effective ban on its use as an authorised UV filter in the European Union [1, 2]. The RAC confirms that the proposed restriction could prevent the release of approximately 13,300 tonnes of Octocrylene into the environment over a ten-year period [1, 2]. Furthermore, both the RAC and SEAC recommend adopting the shorter two-year transition period (RO1) rather than the five-year alternative (RO2), to ensure a faster and greater reduction in environmental risks (80% reduction compared with 50%) [1, 2].


3. Areas of Divergence in Environmental and Methodological Assessments


Although the RAC supports the need for a restriction, its scientific assessment differs significantly from the French approach on several key aspects of hazard assessment, assessment factors and persistence [1, 2].


3.1. Assessment Factors (AFs) and Determination of Aquatic PNECs

This represents the main technical divergence between ANSES and the RAC.

  • French position (ANSES): In its Annex XV dossier, France applied an assessment factor (AF) of 10 for freshwater and 100 for marine water to the Daphnia magna NOEC of 2.66 µg/L. This resulted in a freshwater PNEC of 0.27 µg/L and a marine water PNEC of 0.027 µg/L [1, 2]. France considered that increasing these assessment factors was unnecessary because the Risk Characterisation Ratios (RCRs) already substantially exceeded the critical threshold of 1, even when using these assessment factors [1, 2].


  • Diverging RAC position (ECHA): The RAC challenges the assessment factors selected by France [1, 2]. Under the REACH Guidance (Chapter R.10), applying an assessment factor of 10 requires valid chronic toxicity data covering three distinct trophic levels: algae, invertebrates and fish [2]. However, the RAC invalidated all available acute and chronic studies on fish and algae due to major methodological shortcomings, including nominal test concentrations considerably exceeding the substance's solubility limit and the absence of analytical monitoring of actual exposure concentrations [2]. With only one valid chronic study available (on Daphnia magna), the RAC concludes that the rules established in Guidance R.10 require an assessment factor of 100 for freshwater and 1,000 for marine water (or even 10,000 when relying on acute toxicity data) [2]. The RAC therefore demonstrates that France underestimated the severity of the aquatic hazard and that the appropriate PNEC values should be substantially lower, indicating that actual environmental risks, expressed as RCRs, are even higher than those calculated by France [2].


3.2. Assessment of Persistence (P/vP) and Degradation By-products

A second major divergence concerns the regulatory classification of Octocrylene's persistence.

  • French position (ANSES): ANSES formally concluded that Octocrylene meets the criteria for classification as Persistent (P) and very Persistent (vP) under Annex XIII of REACH. This conclusion was based on mineralisation half-lives exceeding 180 days in water-sediment studies [1, 2].

  • Diverging RAC position: The RAC does not reach a formal conclusion regarding the P/vP status of Octocrylene [2]. The Committee considers that relying solely on the complete mineralisation half-life is excessively conservative, given that significant primary degradation (69.1%) was observed. The RAC calculated a primary degradation half-life of 53.8 days at 12°C (SFO DegT50) [2]. However, the RAC highlights that this primary degradation generates non-extractable residues (NERs) and metabolites or transformation products, such as benzophenone, which may themselves exhibit persistent or very persistent (P/vP) properties [2].


3.3. Rejection of the Marine Degradation Study

France relied on a degradation simulation study conducted in a specific marine water-sediment system to support its marine environmental exposure scenario. The RAC rejected this study because of a significant methodological limitation: a decline in microbial viability of more than 85% by day 100 of the experiment [1, 2]. Consequently, the RAC recommends extrapolating freshwater degradation parameters to the marine environment, resulting in slight modifications to the simulated accumulation kinetics [2].

 

3.4. Methodological Reservations Regarding the Consumer Swimming Scenario

In the consumer exposure assessment based on recreational swimming activities (Consumer Approach – Swimming Scenario), the RAC identifies an inconsistency in the French modelling approach [2]. The French dossier considers the total water volume of freshwater lakes but limits the marine water volume to the immediate coastal zone, while applying debatable tidal and coastal dilution factors ranging from 29% to 50% [2]. Nevertheless, the RAC emphasises that these uncertainties do not affect the overall conclusion: even under the most refined exposure scenarios, the RCRs remain well above 1 [2].


4. Comparative Summary: ANSES (France) vs RAC (ECHA)


The following table provides a comparative overview of the environmental parameters assessed in the two official documents [1, 2].


Environmental Parameter / Issue

ANSES Position (France) [1]

RAC Position (ECHA) [2]

Tonnage and main emission source

1,752 tonnes/year in EU cosmetics. 100% released into the environment (20% during swimming, 80% via WWTPs).

Full agreement with ANSES regarding volumes and environmental release pathways.

Aquatic toxicity

Daphnia magna identified as the most sensitive species. 21-day NOEC = 2.66 µg/L.

Full agreement. Confirms the NOEC of 2.66 µg/L and EC10 of 4.58 µg/L.

Assessment factors (freshwater/marine water)

AF = 10 for freshwater and AF = 100 for marine water, considered sufficient to demonstrate risk.

Major divergence: requires AF = 100 for freshwater and AF = 1,000 for marine water due to invalid fish and algae data. Considers that France underestimated the risk.

Aquatic PNECs

Freshwater PNEC = 0.27 µg/L. Marine water PNEC = 0.027 µg/L.

Considers the French PNECs insufficiently protective. Appropriate PNEC values should be lower.

Persistence (P/vP)

Concludes that Octocrylene is P and vP based on mineralisation half-lives.

Does not reach a formal P/vP conclusion. Considers the mineralisation-based approach excessively conservative (DegT50 = 53.8 days). Highlights concerns regarding persistent metabolites.

Sediments and agricultural soils

Sediment PNEC = 0.926 mg/kg dw. Soil PNEC = 1.95 mg/kg dw.

Full agreement regarding NOEC values (Lumbriculus: 46.3 mg/kg; mung bean: 19.5 mg/kg) and the resulting PNECs.

Recommended restriction option

RO1: concentration limit of 0.001% w/w with a two-year transition period.

Strongly supports RO1 (two years). Rejects RO2 (five years) to avoid approximately 5,000 additional tonnes of environmental releases.

 

Author : Cyril DUROU


5. References

 

  • [1] French Agency for Food, Environmental and Occupational Health & Safety (ANSES). Annex XV Restriction Report – Proposal for a Restriction: Octocrylene (EC No. 228-250-8, CAS No. 6197-30-4). Version 1.0. Maisons-Alfort, France: ANSES; 18 July 2025. Submitted under Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006 (REACH) and published by the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) for public consultation on 24 September 2025. Restriction proposal concerning a maximum concentration of 0.001% w/w Octocrylene in finished cosmetic products.

  • [2] European Chemicals Agency (ECHA), Committee for Risk Assessment (RAC), and Committee for Socio-economic Analysis (SEAC). Opinion on an Annex XV Dossier Proposing Restrictions on Octocrylene (EC No. 228-250-8, CAS No. 6197-30-4). RAC Rapporteurs: Bert-Ove Lund and Patrick Morgan; Advisor: Mike Broderick. References: ECHA/RAC/RES-O-0000007637-64-01/F and ECHA/SEAC/RES-O-0000007656-64-01/F. Adopted by the Committee for Risk Assessment on 4 June 2026; consolidated opinion published on 16 September 2026. Helsinki, Finland: European Chemicals Agency; 2026.

  • [3] Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 November 2009 on cosmetic products, Annex VI (List of UV filters allowed in cosmetic products), entry No. 10. Official Journal of the European Union, L 342, 22 December 2009, pp. 59–209. EUR-Lex.


Need guidance? Speak with our specialists

Select a sector:
How did you hear about us?
bottom of page